In the case, “We’ll Never Be That Kind of Couple: The Variability of Intimate Violence”, through the walls of their new apartment, Emma and Jason begin to hear a couple fight excessively with each other. They make the promise that they would never be like them. After some time, the fights next door got louder and more disturbing until one day, Emma and Jason had their own lash out at each other. First, I’d like to say that if someone is constantly hearing negative stuff, eventually they will become negative too. They tell us since grade school to associate with people of good character. This is a good example as to why. In this case, the first thing I thought about when they were listening to the couple fight every night was, “how long before they start fighting?” It is human nature to adapt qualities, either good or bad, from the people around us. The neighbors were a “bad” couple and after so much exposure to this “bad” even through the walls, it trickled in to a “good” relationship.
It was said in this case that “there is a big variety of violent couples-even ones that include no physical violence but a lot of verbal, psychological, and emotional violence.” In domestic relationships that have begun to get violent, there are many factors that may lead up to that point which include: power, dominance, and influence. However, regardless of what issues may be causing the abuse, it leads into hard emotions.
Hard emotions result from violations of relational expectations and include anger, jealousy, hurt, and guilt. In this case, you see a lot of anger and hurt in both couples in the story and they both need to reframe and repair. This would be easier to do in the situation that Emma and Jason are in, rather than the next door neighbors because they have already hit rock bottom.
In the case of Emma and Jason, there is also an instant where they hear the relationship next door become physical and it worries Emma. She communicated with a friend about calling the cops and she isn’t sure if she should get involved. Soon thereafter, she and Jason begin arguing. Believe it or not, we all have consciousness, and when something is bothering us we take it out on the ones we love. This could have also been the case with this couple as they are both burdened with the idea that they may not be helping someone in need of help.
From my own personal experience I will make it clear to anyone that witnesses or hears abuse on any level……Help!
I remember being the girl in the next room, the one that I know all the neighbors heard and at my worst moments I would pray for them to call the cops or to knock on the door or something. You never know what someone is going through and you never know how the abuse is affecting the person, or even if they will make it out alive. People in the world don’t want to get involved. They don’t think it’s their business, or even think that someone else will help, but in some cases you may be the only person someone is relying on. Someone out there is praying for your help and continuing to suffer because you are too afraid to pick up a damn phone and tell the cops to check it out. Women have been murdered because of these types of neighbors. Many women have been beaten on the streets by men as bystanders walk by without trying to stop it. It is very sad that people are afraid to help other people. So I say this, “if you are afraid to pick up a phone and call the cops, or afraid to knock on the door to do a welfare check, close your eyes and imagine how afraid that women is right now…”
PS. I know men are involved in situations too, I use the case of a women being abused to reflect my point in this case of Emma and Jason and also because research studies and APD conclude that the abuser is almost always a man. No offense to any men reading this. I also take this topic very seriously and think that people need to extend a hand to those that are in abusive relationships.
I have attached the cycle of abuse per APD. If you or anyone you know are in this type of a relationship, break the cycle today!


I really like your post. You stated the case well. I think it is good that you also stated that people should help one another. There have been times I have called the cops on my neighbors and it ended up being the TV. That was a little embarrassing but it sounded so real and violent. I also lived near a couple that would always fight violently and the kids would grab the silverware drawer and run upstairs with it to our apartment. This case the abuser was the woman. Eventually they seperated but got back together. It was also a cycle of substance abuse and lack of communication. We did not have a phone but we would take the kids in so they did not have to be a part of it.
ReplyDeleteI disagree with the idea that Alex and Ana became that kind of couple because they heard their neighbors fighting. People are influenced mainly by the way their parents behaved towards each other and this would be a more likely suspect than the new neighbors. I like your blog though you have put a lot of care into bringing the issue of domestic violence to our awareness.
ReplyDelete-Cezanne Sanchez
I really like your post, and how you incorporate all those pictures and even a domestic violence video in, you are such a thoughtful person. This is a very serious topic, that was also my favorite case study in the module, and I really enjoyed your interpretation of it. Emma and Jason definitely seem to have some issues to work out in their relationship, hopefully they never get to the point of their neighbors.
ReplyDelete- Chanel Rodriguez
WOW!!
ReplyDeleteI think you did a great job of presenting your case study from the video to the pictures it really tied everything together. I like how you incorporated the themes of the book into your case study. Although it is unknown why this couple fights like they do it is certain that need help before things get out of control.